With all this shifting and reorganizing of America's police and intelligence services, it is easy to miss what looks like the beginnings of an executive branch secret police service:
President Bush ordered another shake-up of the nation's intelligence services yesterday, forming new national security divisions within both the FBI and the Justice Department and, for the first time, putting a broad swath of the FBI under the authority of the nation's spy chief.Americans may miss it but the BBC sees it clearly:
...
Civil liberties advocates immediately criticized the changes at the FBI, arguing that they represent a radical step toward the creation of a secret police force in the United States. Many Justice prosecutors and FBI agents had also fiercely opposed the changes but were overruled by Bush's homeland security adviser, Frances Fragos Townsend, officials said.
...
"Spies and cops play different roles and operate under different rules for a reason," said Timothy Edgar, national security counsel for the American Civil Liberties Union. "The FBI is effectively being taken over by a spymaster who reports directly to the White House. . . . It's alarming that the same person who oversees foreign spying will now oversee domestic spying, too."
The BBC's Adam Brookes in Washington says Americans have long resisted the growth of domestic intelligence agencies, believing they pose a threat to civil liberties.Well duh! The FBI was bad enough in its earlier incarnation that kept tabs on labor leaders, bugged civil rights groups, disrupted anti-war organizations, sent threatening letters to Martin Luther King suggesting he commit suicide, engaged in entrapment and provocatureing - and all the while pretending that the Mafia didn't exist (because J. Edgar Hoover got to vacation and gamble on the Mafia's tab as long as he looked the other direction).
The only saving grace about this situation is that the FBI has historically proven to be so incompentent one can only hope that any secret police embodied within it will be equally useless.